aim key cog flag clipboard-pencil podium flare signal lamp pie-chart graph scale2 hammer2 balance traffic-lights road archery wall share2 warning notification-circle circle-minus prohibited book book2 bookmark

Call your nearest office

Or ask us a question

Search our site

What are you looking for?

share

Yes, we know the process of settlement agreement refunds.  Yes, we know the documents that HMRC will require and want signing.  Yes, we have had clients that have now received refunds with more being advised as each week passes.

So what else is there to know?

A fair bit of practical stuff and awareness of what HMRC are doing really.

 

Settlement Agreement Refunds

A practical aspect of the Settlement Agreement is that HMRC have asked on numerous occasions for a copy.

Rather odd as they will have the original.

However, it is a function of HMRC home working, something that is likely to continue for a while yet.

Without the original agreement the case handler can’t evaluate what a refund may be.  If they can’t do that, whilst the eligibility may be fine, figures cannot be cascaded to the taxpayer.  Process delayed until the case handler can get into the office to find it.

Knowing the requirement, we always provide a copy of the fully signed Settlement Agreement where we have it  It accelerates the process.

 

Document Signing

Document signing is another practical aspect to consider.

Firstly, HMRC post gets scanned centrally, which takes time and often pages get detached.  We scan all documents to case handlers direct.

Case handlers will only move matters on from HMRC scans but they will work in the background on documents provided by an agent.

Secondly, with home working, HMRC stockpile post in the office so the signer can work through a volume of documents in one go rather than doing multiple trips.

Knowing that helps manage expectations plus HMRC’s office suite is considerably reduced compared to historic locations.  It is more of a task for an officer to get into an office to sign due to the geographic spread.

 

Decisions

Not all decisions will be favourable for the taxpayer.  Some are bizarre and are being challenged.

HMRC seems to be attempting to find various reasons not to refund even where the settlement was on ‘Voluntary Restitution‘ terms.

The oddest reason yet are VR settlements reached after the striking off of the corporate but HMRC attempting to say Reg 80’s and Section 8’s were valid at the time of settlement despite the company ceasing to exist.  The position is being challenged.

Unless it is clear, remember HMRC has a very slanted view of refund, it doesn’t want to do it.  It doesn’t mean it’s rationale to reach that view is robust.

 

Loans

A few clients have presented to us where loans have not been written off or the arrangement collapsed.  This seems to have been on the misunderstanding that to do so would trigger Part 7a and a further charge.

Yes it is a relevant step for Part 7a, however, Para 59, S554Z5 (ITEPA 2003) etc kick in to apply overlapping relief provisions to render the w/o an effectively neutral event.

If the loans still exist it can result in additional IHT charges.  HMRC are monitoring and policing this aspect.

Even if there is no additional IHT the structure still exists and there will probably be ongoing compliance costs when nothing is happening, or likely to happen, with it going forward.  A cost hole with no enduring benefit?

 

Summary

Remember, the clock is ticking, settlement agreement refund claims have to be made before 1 October 2021.

There are numerous practical aspects that arise from the claim process; some good, some less so.

 

We have a wealth of experience dealing with matters involving Morse Refunds and Voluntary Restitution Settlements, please get in touch.

If you cannot find the information you need on our website, please contact Andy Maxfield using our contact form or email directly to amaxfield@hwca.com

Be the first to comment

Get in touch

Whatever issue or question you have, we’ve got the answer.
If you want to get in
touch then please complete our form.

Birmingham

Sterling House
71 Francis Road
Edgbaston
Birmingham
B16 8SP

Leeds

Sterling House
1 Sheepscar Court
Meanwood Road
Leeds
LS7 2BB

London

New Derwent House
69 – 73 Theobalds Road
London
WC1X 8TA

Our addresses

Birmingham

Sterling House
71 Francis Road
Edgbaston
Birmingham
B16 8SP

Tel: 0121 456 1613

Leeds

Sterling House
1 Sheepscar Court
Meanwood Road
Leeds
LS7 2BB

Tel: 0113 3981100

London

New Derwent House
69 – 73 Theobalds Road
London
WC1X 8TA

Tel: 0207 025 4650